Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started

Songs with non-musical sound effects

Here’s wishing all the readers a very Happy Diwali!!

Divine Flame, S.L.Haldankar, Water Colour, NGMA, New Delhi Collection

Posted on Trivia – The Spice of Life on 24/10/2022

While writing the post on Songs of echo and reverberation, it occurred to me that there are many songs where onscreen action is expressed through non-musical sounds that are not masked by the song but go alongside. Such sounds make these songs special. When I say non-musical sounds, I mean sounds such as water filling, glass breaking, the oars striking the water creating ripples and so on. Obviously, all songs have on screen action but not all incorporate these sounds in the songs. Adding sounds to the recorded track would warrant more technical acumen, ingenuity and hard work. The added sound that is inserted must sound genuine, it must gel with the song and perfectly enhance the impact of the onscreen action. Therefore, such songs would need to have a master sound mixer and recordist to get the right effect.

Mangesh Desai – Sound Re-recordist and mixer
Image Courtesy : https://www.filmcompanion.in/

Even at the cost of digressing a little, I feel it is important to mention the greatness of the one and only Mangesh Desai (1923-1985) who was a sound re-recordist and mixer par excellence. When the credits of many a film roll, you are sure to find his name. He was a magician with sound. He was one of those whom the entire film fraternity respected but feared too. It is said that the film release date was decided as per his diary. He would never compromise with his work. He was unabashed in his criticism if he felt that something was amiss. Despite working behind the scenes, he was a revered figure who made a mark. He was the talented music director Vasant Desai’s nephew. He participated in the Quit India Movement and even spent a few years in prison. Vasant Desai took him to V.Shantaram after he was released from prison; there was no looking back after that.

In the list that I am putting together, I have tried to identify different sounds that have been incorporated in as many songs. The sounds that I am focussing on are not the sounds of improvised musical instruments (especially those found in R.D.Burman’s songs) but the atypical ones. These are also pretty mundane sounds but to make them a part of a song requires some skill. The songs are largely of the golden era. It must also be said here that the sound in some cases is only at the beginning of the song and in others could figure anywhere in the song or even throughout the song.

1) A Punctured TyreTaxi Driver (1954)Chaahe Koi Khush HoSahir Ludhianvi- S.D.Burman – Kishore Kumar, Johny Walker and chorus. This is a fun song which justifies living beyond one’s means to get the best out of life. It advocates a carefree attitude to life. Dev Anand, Johny Walker and their friends get together and have a day out in a khatara. The tyre gets punctured and the sound of the air escaping from the tyre is incorporated in the song. So is the sound of the air being pumped very skilfully inserted (2:56 to 3:21 in the video clip below). Johny’s commentary, which the song is peppered with, makes it very hilarious.

2) Of the Clock Ticking – Albela (1951) – Mere Dil Ki Ghadi Kare Tik Tik Tik – Rajendra Krishan – C.Ramchandra – Lata Mangeshkar & C Ramchandra. This graceful dance number by Geeta Bali and Bhagwan is so canorous. The song begins with the sound of the clock ticking at the stroke of midnight. Bhagwan’s imagination turns wild as he imagines Geeta Bali (a famous stage actress in the movie) emerging from the clock. The sound of the clock ticking continues till Lata starts singing (0:00 to 0:27 in the video link below). This sound effect makes the lyrics sound more realistic.

3) Of water filling in the tub – Abhinetri (1970) – O Ghata Sawari Thodi Thodi Baawri -Majrooh Sultanpuri – Laxmikant Pyarelal – Lata Mangeshkar. This is a wonderful rain song with Hema Malini looking stunningly beautiful. Towards the latter half of the song, Hema Malini goes to take a bath after sweating it out. What caught my attention is the sound of the water filling the bathtub (3:06 to 3:15 in the video link below) which has been incorporated in the song. In fact, another song which speaks of bathroom singing would have sounded much better with sound effects is Thande Thande Paani Se (Pati Patni Aur Woh, 1980). There aren’t many songs which capture this sound in a song.

4) The Train Whistle – Pakeezah (1971)- Chalte Chalte Yun Hi Koi – Kaifi Azmi – Ghulam Mohammad-Lata Mangeshkar. There are umpteen songs that have the train whistle added especially those shot on or near a train. However, this song is very unique for it has nothing to do with a train journey. It is said that the train whistle towards the end of the song was added by Mangesh Desai, much against the wishes of Naushad. Naushad later understood that the whistle had by no means marred the beauty of the mujra.

Screen grab from opening credits of Pakeezah

Anyone who has seen the film would understand the significance of the train whistle, for Meena Kumari has met the stranger she falls in love with on a train. Thus, the whistle is a potent aural mnemonic for her unknown lover(5:22 onwards in the video clip below). This is a sound that is cherished by music lovers. Here is a screen grab from the credits featuring Mangesh Desai’s name.

5) Sound effect of the badminton shuttlecock hitting the racquet – Dhal Gaya Din – (Humjoli, 1970) – Anand Bakshi – Laxmikant Pyarelal – Md.Rafi and Asha Bhosle. This song from the movie Humjoli is a perfect example of how not to play badminton. Both Jeetendra and Leena Chandawarkar are rather pathetic. There is no finesse and the focus is on romancing. They are not appropriately dressed to play either. Yet, there is a fun element in this song, especially because the sound of the shuttlecock hitting the racquet is made an integral part of the song’s rhythm, very innovatively, by the music directors (0:27 to 1:25 in the video link below). That is perhaps the only role badminton has to play in the song.

6) Thunder and lightning effect – Dil Tera Deewaana Hain Sanam – Dil Tera Deewana (1962) – Shailendra – Shankar Jaikishan – Lata Mangeshkar & Md.Rafi. There are many rain songs which have incorporated the sound of thunder and lightning. However, I chose this because the lyrics also refer to lightning. The vocal prelude is :-

bijli giraa ke aap khud bijli se dar gaye
ham saadgi pe aapki lillaah mar gaye

The sound effect introduced just for two seconds (0:10 to 0:12 in the video link below) makes the lyrics more meaningful.

7) The oars hitting the water – Nadiya Chale Chale Re Dhaara – Safar (1970) – Indeevar – Kalyanji Anandji – Manna Dey & Chorus. This is a sound that is heard throughout the song. It is almost in sync with the spirit of the song that one has to keep pushing oneself and not stop. Anandji in one of his interviews (from 14:19 to15:56 in interview below) in fact describes very interestingly how with several trial and error methods, this sound was created. The effect was finally created by using moong seeds in a cane winnowing basket.

Cane winnowing basket
Image Courtesy : https://mycookwareshop.com/

8) Rahat and other farm sounds Mere Desh Ki Dharti – Upkar (1967) – Gulshan Bawra – Kalyanji Anandji – Mahendra Kapoor & Chorus. If there is one song that captures the beauty and simplicity of our village life, it is this. It beautifully showcases the hardworking farmer of India who sweats it out to provide for himself and the nation at large. The sounds associated with the farm activities – the chirping of the birds, the bells of the bulls, the rahat, the water gushing – all of them feature very naturally in this song. The song took 18 hours to record because of the various effects as Anandji describes in the interview below (from 20:15 to 21:32 in the interview). The sound re-recordist of this movie is obviously Mangesh Desai!!

9) Sounds of NatureNindiya Se Jaagi Bahaar – Hero (1983) – Anand Bakshi- Laxmikant Pyarelal – Lata Mangeshkar. This is one of my favourite songs (apart from Suhana Safar from Madhumati) which has some wonderful sounds of nature – the birds chirping, the water gushing shot in picturesque surroundings. Featuring Meenakshi Seshadri who left a mark despite her rather short acting career, it shows how a song like this can be shot tastefully. The manner in which Meenakshi tries to match the notes of the chirping birds is interesting.

10) Rifle being readied for firing and glass breaking sound – Jab Tak Hain Jaan – Sholay (1975) – Anand Bakshi – R.D.Burman – Lata Mangeshkar. If there was one movie that was known for the genius of Mangesh Desai it was Sholay. The sound effect of the coin rolling was phenomenal. For the coin-flipping scene, Desai suggested to the director Sippy that the sound of the coin flying should reverberate in theatres. That effect was achieved by flipping a coin against a wall and letting it roll down a flight of steps during the sound mixing.

The sound design created during this dance song in Gabbar Singh’s den has the sound of bottles breaking all around her and of the rifle being readied for firing to mount pressure on Basanti.

This brings me to the end of my playlist of 10 songs. I am sure there are many more songs with discrete non musical sound effects used to bolster the sound of music. Sound effects when used in moderation and with precision can surely raise the song to a completely different level. May I also add that this post helped me to learn about the genius of Mangesh Desai which I was hitherto ignorant about. Those behind the scenes are as important as those in front for the film to become a masterpiece.

Disclaimer

anitamultitasker.wordpress.com claims no credit for any image, screenshots or songs posted on this site. The images and screenshots are the copyright of their original owners. The song links are shared from YouTube, daily motion and other platforms only to make the post audio visual. The copyright of these songs rests with the respective owners, producers and music companies.

9 thoughts on “Songs with non-musical sound effects

  1. Anitaji,
    Let me first wish you and your family a very happy diwali.
    And a very interesting post to celebrate the occasion. I liked the idea and very well exicuted.

    The songs which I could instantly recollect for the theme were,

    Pani Pani Re from Machis that incorporates sound of flowing water

    Title track of Joggers Park that has chirping of birds in the opening music. A similar sound can be heard in the film track of Yeh Tanhai hay re hay from Tere Ghar Ke Samne. It’s not there in the record version.

    Pyar Mein Dil Pe Maar De Goli that incorporates firing of a gun, the same sounds can be heard in Aankhiyon Se goli maare from Dulhe Raja.

    The title track of Dil Apna Preet Parai opens with sounds of Fire crackers.

    Thare Rahiyo from Pakeezah has a number of added non musical sounds including a firing of a gunshot and breaking of glass.

    There’s ringing of cycle bells in a few songs. As it’s not a musical instrument, it may find a place on the list. The most prominent example is, Ban Ke Yeh Panchhi Gaye from Anari.

    Oh!
    That was quite a loooong comment.

    Anup
    🙂

    Like

  2. And,
    I forgot to add,
    The sounds of utensils in O betaji are o babuji in Albela.

    The movie version of Arji Hamari yeh marzi hamari from Naukari has sounds of typewriter being used to type an application. The song actually opens with it. I’m not sure if it’s there in the record version.

    The sounds of blowing wind in the opening music of Ae Mere Humsafar from the 90s movie, Baazigar.

    Anup

    🙂

    Like

  3. Can we consider,
    Sobbing or crying sounds in the songs for this theme?
    If yes,
    Mera pyar mujhse rootha from Kalakar has coughing in the movie version. One of the songs of noorjahan also has coughing even in the record version if I am correct. I’m not been able to recollect the song.
    And,
    I think Aur Is Dil Mein Kya Rakha Hai has sobbing sounds, when Asha Bhosle enters the song.

    And,
    The song, Jawan e janeman opens with a ringing of a telephone, does it qualify?
    Similarly,
    The song, what is mobile number by Sonu Nigam and Alka Yagnik has ringing of phone.

    I’ve a query.

    Does the song from pakeezah, chalte chalte yunhi koi, really fits? Let me explain.

    The train whistle is not a real one. I mean it’s not recorded live from a real train whistle, but recreated in a studio with musical instruments. So for me it’s not exactly an added sound. Do you agree?

    Otherwise, we can add train rhthym songs as well or songs with tonga rhythm as well to the list. But we know these are not real sounds, but recreated ones.

    Anup
    🙂

    Like

    1. Anupji, thanks a lot for the Diwali Wishes!!
      Thanks a lot for all the wonderful songs added by you!
      Can we consider,
      Sobbing or crying sounds in the songs for this theme?

      The sounds that I typically had in mind were those not produced by human beings.

      Otherwise, we can add train rhthym songs as well or songs with tonga rhythm as well to the list. But we know these are not real sounds, but recreated ones.

      Well, as the name of the post suggests clearly, these are non-musical sounds which have nothing to do with the rhythm of the song. These sounds are only added for effect to make the on screen action look more authentic in a song. The song would be just as complete without these added sounds. Thus, the tonga and train rhythm songs will not qualify.

      Does the song from pakeezah, chalte chalte yunhi koi, really fits? Let me explain.
      The train whistle is not a real one. I mean it’s not recorded live from a real train whistle, but recreated in a studio with musical instruments. So for me it’s not exactly an added sound. Do you agree?

      Many of these added sounds are actually artificially created and added in the studio. Even the sound of the oars hitting the water in Nadiya Chale Chale Re Dhaara (please hear the relevant part of the interview of Anandji which I have mentioned in the post along with the song) was created artificially with moong seeds and a winnowing basket (सूप). These are simulated sounds.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. A wonderful selection of songs, Anitaji. There are so many of this type, and you have picked some of the best. Here are a couple of others I like; I hope they fit:

    Tinkling glasses in Chura liya hai tumne jo dil ko:

    Storm winds, thunder, etc in Gagan jhanjhana raha, which I think is a great example since the sounds continue through most of the song:

    Falling rain, pounding pestles, in Rim jhim barse paani:

    Like

    1. Thanks a lot for liking the playlist! Yes, there are many songs with added sounds especially the rain drops, thunder and lightning given the penchant for rain songs in many a movie.
      Chura Liya Hain would not qualify as the tinkling sound is used to create music. R.D.Burman could use anything to produce music (even brooms like in the Padosan song Mere saamne wali khidki mein)
      The other two songs fit perfectly. I was indeed enthralled by the sound effect and picturization of the song from Pardesi is so true to life. Life in rural Maharashtra is very realistically depicted.

      Like

  5. Anita,
    This is a wonderful post. Highly informative for introducing us to Mangesh Desai and making us notice sounds. I remembered the opening scene of Sergio Leone’s ‘Once Upon A Time in The West’ where three baddies are waiting at the railway station for the train which will bring their colleague and since they have nothing else to do, Leone shows their ennui by different sounds occurring naturally:

    Like

    1. Thanks a lot for appreciating the post, AKji! It was indeed a learning experience for me too. We usually do not look at the technical aspects of film making. There are so many who work together – both in front and behind the camera – to make a film. I loved the clip that you shared. The sounds are so beautifully captured. So much is conveyed even though not even a word is spoken.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: